advanced search
Contact Us tayyar.org
 
The Orange Room - forum.tayyar.org
 



Notices
The Orange Room Discuss anything related to Lebanon, Lebanese Politics, Breaking News and Live Updates on Major Events related to Lebanon & the World

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
  (#21 (permalink)) Old
Orange Room Supporter
 
Abou Sandal's Avatar
 
Online
Posts: 9,895
Thanks: 1,460
Thanked 2,400 Times in 1,498 Posts
Last Online: 57 Minutes Ago
Join Date: Mon Jun 2007
View Abou Sandal's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by King Rami View Post
and Manar Tv always shows stuff from the Israeli TV stations, where's the problem?
No problem at all.

Yet for the accuracy and definition of the action itself,one needs to make a difference.

Showing clips or reportages or footages about the enemy,is one thing.

But buying or conducting direct exclusive interviews with the enemy,or talking or having conversations with him, is called "direct contact with the enemy".

The only problem is that it is prohibited by the law.

We're telling them to change the law and do whatever they wish...No problem.

Personally,I would also prefer to see someone having contact with the enemy before my eyes,than do it behind my back...Especially those who shout and scream about the "3ourouba" day and night...Those,i prefer to see them free to do whatever they want...just to see how far they would go
Sponsored Links
  (#22 (permalink)) Old
Registered Member
 
e.kid's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 364
Thanks: 113
Thanked 49 Times in 40 Posts
Last Online: 1 Day Ago
Join Date: Thu Aug 2006
View e.kid's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abou Sandal View Post
According to the law,this is totally illegal.

Maybe we should call the "Islamic Arabic resistance" and ask them to do something.
Would you please post the law articles you are refering to
the one that makes it illegal
  (#23 (permalink)) Old
Orange Room Supporter
 
Abou Sandal's Avatar
 
Online
Posts: 9,895
Thanks: 1,460
Thanked 2,400 Times in 1,498 Posts
Last Online: 57 Minutes Ago
Join Date: Mon Jun 2007
View Abou Sandal's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by e.kid View Post
Would you please post the law articles you are refering to
the one that makes it illegal
I don't have it at hand.You have to trust me,or do you search.
  (#24 (permalink)) Old
Registered Member
 
King Rami's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 6,575
Blog Entries: 1
Thanks: 689
Thanked 723 Times in 383 Posts
Last Online: 12 Hours Ago
Join Date: Sun Apr 2005
View King Rami's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abou Sandal View Post
No problem at all.

Yet for the accuracy and definition of the action itself,one needs to make a difference.

Showing clips or reportages or footages about the enemy,is one thing.

But buying or conducting direct exclusive interviews with the enemy,or talking or having conversations with him, is called "direct contact with the enemy".

The only problem is that it is prohibited by the law.

We're telling them to change the law and do whatever they wish...No problem.

Personally,I would also prefer to see someone having contact with the enemy before my eyes,than do it behind my back...Especially those who shout and scream about the "3ourouba" day and night...Those,i prefer to see them free to do whatever they want...just to see how far they would go
they can't apply the Lebanese law on the rest of the arabian countries, ftv is a fada2iyye that broadcasts from Lebanon and it has viewers from all the Arabian countries
The Following User Says Thank You to King Rami For This Useful Post:
Abou Sandal (14th March 2009)
  (#25 (permalink)) Old
Registered Member
 
e.kid's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 364
Thanks: 113
Thanked 49 Times in 40 Posts
Last Online: 1 Day Ago
Join Date: Thu Aug 2006
View e.kid's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abou Sandal View Post
I don't have it at hand.You have to trust me,or do you search.
1- Unfortunatly, i dont trust anyone in politics
2- Until proven otherwise, i will say that there is nothing illegal about it
3- That is the main problem in lebanon, everyone wants to make up a law that fits his "divine" agenda
  (#26 (permalink)) Old
Orange Room Moderator
 
December Rain's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 742
Thanks: 124
Thanked 245 Times in 147 Posts
Last Online: 2 Days Ago
Join Date: Sun Mar 2008
View December Rain's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

ok this is an excerpt from a passage about the state of the media in lebanon in one of the most respected and professional media websites in the region menassat.com :

Quote:
......"Journalists also respect other taboos, such as Lebanon’s relation with Israel.

Lebanon is still officially at war with Israel, and it is illegal for any Lebanese citizen, including journalists, to enter into contact with an Israeli citizen.......
i will try to find the actual law about the the issue although it's gonna be hard to find it on the internet i might have to go to a library and scan the law or something...i doubt i will be able to do that in the near future, so if anyone has the law plz feel free to post it..
And people remember the issue is not about whether doing an interview with an israeli is wrong or not, we can keep on arguing for ages about whether it's wrong or not but the issue is the following:

Is interviewing an Israeli against the Lebanese law ??

You can be with or against a law prohibiting journalists from contacting an israeli...but if such a law exists u have to abide by it, and if u don't like it u can work to change it....And again, until it is changed u have to respect it.
The Following User Says Thank You to December Rain For This Useful Post:
Abou Sandal (14th March 2009)
  (#27 (permalink)) Old
Orange Room Supporter
 
Abou Sandal's Avatar
 
Online
Posts: 9,895
Thanks: 1,460
Thanked 2,400 Times in 1,498 Posts
Last Online: 57 Minutes Ago
Join Date: Mon Jun 2007
View Abou Sandal's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by King Rami View Post
they can't apply the Lebanese law on the rest of the arabian countries, ftv is a fada2iyye that broadcasts from Lebanon and it has viewers from all the Arabian countries
Lucky Arabs...What would they do without that enlightening media?
The Following User Says Thank You to Abou Sandal For This Useful Post:
King Rami (14th March 2009)
  (#28 (permalink)) Old
Orange Room Supporter
 
taifoon's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 6,219
Thanks: 574
Thanked 635 Times in 369 Posts
Last Online: 22nd May 2009
Join Date: Fri Mar 2005
View taifoon's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

7atta ma tekbar aktar, not that I particularly like it myself, them stupid laws, or digging the Lebanese law books after them, but here's the closest I could get on this issue ( also peppered with a nostalgia touch for some, and a reminder for others..)


Lebanon annual Report 2002

Lebanon annual Report 2002

The year 2001 was marked by the arrest of over 200 anti-Syrian Christian militants accused of "hatching an anti-Syrian plot with the Israelis". During the year two well-known journalists were harassed after publishing critical articles about the army. In general, journalists are not protected against warnings and even threats by the intelligence services.

In August 2001 the army intelligence services arrested over 200 anti-Syrian Christian militants accused of "hatching an anti-Syrian plot with the Israelis". A few days after these raids a communiqué put out by the Council of Ministers noted that the information minister was "charged with applying the terms of the law on the media" to stop "abuse by the media which threatens national security".

Prior to that the CNA, the broadcasting authority, had sent a document to the Council of Ministers concerning the coverage of events on 7 and 8 August by the broadcasting media. This report specified, in particular, that the channel MTV (reputedly close to General Aoun) "had not respected the pluralistic nature of news [...], had caused viewers to be worried by making them fear a change in the nature of the democratic government in Lebanon [...], had openly challenged political and security institutions in such a way as to threaten public order". Two well-known journalists were victims of harassment after publishing critical articles about the doings of the army, in particular. In general, journalists are not protected against warnings and even threats from the intelligence services.

The Lebanese audio-visual scene is nevertheless far more varied than that of other countries in the Arab world. In 2001 the sixth television channel was allowed to broadcast news bulletins. NTV thus joined Télé-Liban (state-owned), NBN and LBC, (owned by pro-Syrian rulers or people close to the government), MTV (independent), Future TV (owned by Rafik Hariri, the prime-minister) and al Manar (owned by the Hizbollah Shiite Party).

One journalist arrested

On 9 August 2001 police arrested Yehia Houjairi, cameraman for the Kuwaiti state television channel, outside the law courts where he was filming a demonstration against the raid on anti-Syrian circles. He was released only after the intervention of the chairman of the photographers union.

Two journalists attacked

Hussein el Moulla, photographer for Associated Press, and Sami Ayad, photographer for the daily An Nahar, were arrested on 9 August 2001 outside the Beirut law courts. They were covering a demonstration against the wave of arrests of militants and sympathisers of the CPL (Free Patriotic Movement) and Lebanese forces on 5 and 7 August in Beirut. Hussein el Moulla was hit by a plainclothes intelligence police officer of whom he was taking a photo. Sami Ayad was taking photos of demonstrators manhandled by intelligence police when unidentified persons demanded he hand over his films. When he refused they hit him before running away.

Pressure and obstruction

Security police confiscated the passport of Samir Kassir, editorialist with the daily An Nahar, on 28 March 2001 on his return from Amman where he had attended an Arab summit. They told him that they wanted to "check the conditions in which he obtained a passport". In an editorial on 16 March 2001 the journalist had criticised recent demonstrations of force by the army and security services in the country. After his return from Amman he was followed by unmarked police cars for several days.

In 2000 the director of the security police, General Jamil Al-Sayeed, had already phoned the journalist to threaten him after publication of an article in An Nahar. In that article the journalist had criticised the incapacity of the intelligence services to prevent incidents occurring between the army and armed Islamists in the north of the country. His passport was restored to him on 11 April.

In early June a warrant of arrest was issued against Raghida Dergham, manager of the Al Hayat office in New York. This journalist of Lebanese and US nationality failed to appear in the military court on 1 June. She was charged with participating in a seminar organised on 19 May 2000 by the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, in which Uri Lubrani, former Israeli government coordinator for South Lebanon, had also participated
.

The journalist was accused of "contact with the enemy". Lebanese law stipulates that journalists are prohibited from meeting Israelis.
Charges against her were reportedly also related to her critical coverage in 2000 of the quarrel between Lebanon and the United Nations about the demarcation of the Israeli-Lebanese border.

On 18 June 2001 a CNN crew, composed of a British national, Mr. Sadler, his German cameraman Christian Streib, a driver and the Lebanese producer, Nada Husseini, were shot at while doing a report in the Hermel region in north-eastern Lebanon where cannabis is grown. The origin of the shots was not identified. According to Mr. Sadler, the group then fell into an ambush by about ten men armed with machine guns, pistols and a rifle with telescopic sight. They forced the television crew to get out of their car, while shooting in all directions. The assailants confiscated the journalists’ two cameras but gave their personal effects, which they had also confiscated, back to them.

Antoine Bassil, correspondent for the Saudi Arabian television channel MBC, and Habib Younis, sub-editor of the daily Al Hayat, were arrested at their homes on 16 and 19 August, without a warrant of arrest. They were then questioned in the absence of a lawyer. These measures were part of the raids carried out in August by army intelligence services on anti-Syrian Christian militants. The two journalists were accused of "contact with the enemy" (Israel). Their arrest was not related to their professional activity.

Tunisian journalist Taoufik Ben Brik was prevented from boarding a plane on 3 November from Paris to Beirut where he had been invited to attend the anti-globalisation summit. An airline employee explained to him: "Your security cannot be guaranteed".
  (#29 (permalink)) Old
Registered Member
 
e.kid's Avatar
 
Offline
Posts: 364
Thanks: 113
Thanked 49 Times in 40 Posts
Last Online: 1 Day Ago
Join Date: Thu Aug 2006
View e.kid's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Quote:
Originally Posted by December Rain View Post
ok this is an excerpt from a passage about the state of the media in lebanon in one of the most respected and professional media websites in the region menassat.com :



i will try to find the actual law about the the issue although it's gonna be hard to find it on the internet i might have to go to a library and scan the law or something...i doubt i will be able to do that in the near future, so if anyone has the law plz feel free to post it..
And people remember the issue is not about whether doing an interview with an israeli is wrong or not, we can keep on arguing for ages about whether it's wrong or not but the issue is the following:

Is interviewing an Israeli against the Lebanese law ??

You can be with or against a law prohibiting journalists from contacting an israeli...but if such a law exists u have to abide by it, and if u don't like it u can work to change it....And again, until it is changed u have to respect it.
1- If it doesnt exist, you dont have to respect it
and until someone find it and post it, it doesnt exist

2- Was the journalist libaneese ? what you posted is about journalist interviewing israelis, not TV station airing an interview, buying an interview, or ordering in interview.

3- Even if there is a law, it has to apply specificaly to thisz case BUT NOT to Manar, LBC, ... airing interviews about israelis

4- If it exists, I have to agree with Sandal that it is hypocrite, and shoud be changed
  (#30 (permalink)) Old
Registered Member
 
dodzi's Avatar
 
Online
Posts: 3,942
Thanks: 606
Thanked 664 Times in 446 Posts
Last Online: 37 Minutes Ago
Join Date: Fri Jan 2006
View dodzi's Photo Album
Default 14th March 2009

Guys, what's the big deal?

Journalists are like the IRC... They should be allowed to go everywhere, interview anyone, and cover any story!

If all countries condemned Israel and boycotted it, who would be there to tell the truth? Journalists should have a free pass!

During the Gaza war, there was a Lebanese ship planning on going to Gaza and help with the relief efforts. There were among them Lebanese doctors! Should they be prosecuted too?
Closed Thread

  The Orange Room - forum.tayyar.org The Orange Room Main Forums The Orange Room

Tags
future, interviewing, israeli, personnalities


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

 
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Forum Jump

Forums Directory