biased school books in Lebanon

[ius]

Originally Posted by Armenian

I just asked a question

and you clearly gave an answer to it. And with this answer you admitted that:

- You haven’t studied about the events I mentioned
- Israel have committed crimes and massacres

I was just trying to prove that you contradict yourself sometimes

( P.S. Btw I'm all for teaching history as it is without censoring)

Thank you!!

You are dead wrong. I lived through the events you mentioned and know exactly what happened. I have a completely different point of view than you about what occurred. And where did I contradict myself???

I find it hard to believe you are objective in any way since you believe Israel committed the worst massacres and crimes in history. That is 100% false.

[ohyeah]

Originally Posted by ius

Not at all, it is more important for Arabs to teach Arabs that for 1000 years they were dead wrong about an issue and committed great crimes against humanity. That should lead to more humility and tolerance for debate. Isn't it more important to teach the crimes of your own society so that they will not be repeated?

Plz I don't get it. as I said all the world commit slave trade and never considered it as a crime not only Arab but also western eastern and Jews and Isma'il Pasha - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia wagged many wars to stop that trade.OK that what will be learned

History has happened and ended -------> give hint about it.
History which happen and continued and affect the lives of many pupils------>many books must be taught about it.

[roch10452]

Originally Posted by ius

You are dead wrong. I lived through the events you mentioned and know exactly what happened. I have a completely different point of view than you about what occurred. And where did I contradict myself???

I find it hard to believe you are objective in any way since you believe Israel committed the worst massacres and crimes in history. That is 100% false.

Ok Isreal is number two
or three
well anyway its between the Top Ten

back to the subject

I hope FPMers here go back to their old believes and work on stopping all kind of bans... on books or singers

[ohyeah]

Originally Posted by ius

You are dead wrong. I lived through the events you mentioned and know exactly what happened. I have a completely different point of view than you about what occurred. And where did I contradict myself???

I find it hard to believe you are objective in any way since you believe Israel committed the worst massacres and crimes in history. That is 100% false.

what do you call massacres started 1923- now? It is made in 20th century not in the middle age.

[ius]

Originally Posted by ohyeah

what do you call massacres started 1923- now? It is made in 20th century not in the middle age.

What massacres are you talking about?
Are they the following:
1929 Hebron massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
1929 Safed massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Arab Massacres of Jews before 1948 | Middle East Facts Weblog

I studied about those in school? Did you? Do you think these should be put in Lebanese books? Or should you ban teaching them?

[Armenian]

Originally Posted by ius

You are dead wrong. I lived through the events you mentioned and know exactly what happened. I have a completely different point of view than you about what occurred. And where did I contradict myself???

I find it hard to believe you are objective in any way since you believe Israel committed the worst massacres and crimes in history. That is 100% false.

My friend I lived under the Israeli bombs for more than 10 years. What are you talking about?

I didn't have fuel to go to work, bridges were down, my sister ( 4 years old) was traumatized. Why?

How can you have lived through the events when the massacres were happening here, next to me?

In the meantime I don't deny any kind of terrorism committed against Israel.

In your previous reply, you clearly admitted that massacres were committed by Israel, and now in this post you deny it... You see where I saw the contradiction of yours?

Thank you!!

[ohyeah]

Originally Posted by ius

What massacres are you talking about?
Are they the following:
1929 Hebron massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
1929 Safed massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Arab Massacres of Jews before 1948 | Middle East Facts Weblog

I studied about those in school? Did you? Do you think these should be put in Lebanese books? Or should you ban teaching them?

I also have a list and be sure it longer than yours and 2 list must be taught and that would be the best thing happened.

The question is why did this people(Jews) are in Palestinians land?

[ius]

Originally Posted by Armenian

My friend I lived under the Israeli bombs for more than 10 years. What are you talking about?

I didn't have fuel to go to work, bridges were down, my sister ( 4 years old) was traumatized. Why?

How can you have lived through the events when the massacres were happening here, next to me?

In the meantime I don't deny any kind of terrorism committed against Israel.

In your previous reply, you clearly admitted that massacres were committed by Israel, and now in this post you deny it... You see where I saw the contradiction of yours?

Thank you!!

Where did I clearly admit that Israel commits massacres? You are finding something that isn't there. I clearly admit people died in Qana etc., but they were not massacres. They were either mistakes or collateral damage.

Israel only attacked Lebanon when Lebanon attacked Israel. Clearly you do not think so but that does not change the facts. As long as Lebanon is a base to attack Israel from, Lebanon will pay a price.

In fact, I really don't care what you think is terrorism against Israel or not as long as you stop attacks from Lebanon into Israel.

[ius]

Originally Posted by ohyeah

I also have a list and be sure it longer than yours and 2 list must be taught.

The question is why did this people(Jews) are in Palestinians land?

Open a thread and we can discuss it. What you are asking is an interesting question but will not help find any future solution.

[ohyeah]

Originally Posted by ius

Where did I clearly admit that Israel commits massacres? You are finding something that isn't there. I clearly admit people died in Qana etc., but they were not massacres. They were either mistakes or collateral damage.

Israel only attacked Lebanon when Lebanon attacked Israel. Clearly you do not think so but that does not change the facts. As long as Lebanon is a base to attack Israel from, Lebanon will pay a price.

In fact, I really don't care what you think is terrorism against Israel or not as long as you stop attacks from Lebanon into Israel.

What about Deir Yassin?.